AIA Green - Family Health Care News

Health Check: does brain training make you smarter?

No one disputes that extensive training on a specific task will improve performance on that task.Paul Boxley

No one who has kept their head out of the sand over the past several years needs to be told “brain training” is a hot topic. And it’s big business too, with advocates using claims such as “personal training designed by scientists” to market their wares.

Decades of studies in both laboratory animals and humans have demonstrated the capacity of the brain for some degree of plasticity. This can be extremely beneficial; after someone suffers a stroke, for instance, and has to relearn some basic abilities.

But is there any evidence that specific “brain training” can improve overall performance? Or is it all hype and hyperbole?

For many, not one

The cornerstone of scientific progress is the demonstration of evidence-based effects rather than a media vortex of gee-wizz findings in individuals, no matter how compelling these may be for the television viewer.

Sceptics argue that brain-training studies claiming to demonstrate significant effects lack more general applicability and have shown only very specific kinds of improvement.

Meanwhile, proponents of brain training argue studies failing to demonstrate effects employ flawed approaches, including unsatisfactory application of recommended methods.

The key question is generalizability of benefits – the holy grail of brain training.

The key question for assessing the benefits of brain training is the generalizability of benefits.Daniela Hartmann

No one really disputes that extensive training on a specific task will improve performance on that task. But the acid test for brain training is whether it can be reliably demonstrated that training on some tasks transfers more widely to a range of other tasks and thought processes.

In the largest study undertaken in this area to date, researchers were patently unable to demonstrate a generalisation of training across tasks.

They conducted a six-week online study in which 11,430 participants trained several times each week on cognitive tasks designed to improve reasoning, memory, planning, visuospatial skills and attention. Improvement effects were task specific and failed to transfer to other untrained tasks.

But in a more recent high-profile study undertaken in older individuals, another group of researchers used a video game in which players were required to drive and identify specific road signs.

After training, older individuals, aged 60 to 85 years, became more proficient than untrained individuals in their 20s. Their performance levels were sustained for six months, even without additional training.

Perhaps most critically, these researchers reported that older adults performed better at other attention and working memory tests as well, demonstrating the transferability of benefits from the training game to different cognitive functions.

But there’s been much criticism of the study’s findings; for example, with respect to the relatively small number of participants involved.

The bigger picture

And so it goes. Volleys are fired back and forth between the two camps against the backdrop of more general and far-reaching considerations that currently appear to stack up on the side of the sceptics.

It’s widely accepted among working scientists that it’s much more challenging to publish findings that demonstrate non-significant outcomes compared with findings that demonstrate statistically significant differences. So, there’s a potential publication bias against studies of brain training that fail to demonstrate an effect.

But where does this all leave us?

It may be that brain training will show generalizability only from some specific tasks onto others.

There have been claims, for instance, that brain training may improve intelligence (which remains an inchoate concept), or that brain training can rewire the prefrontal cortex or its connections – or both.

The latter (alluded to by researchers who did the video game study above) may be beneficial, given that prefrontal brain regions are known to be engaged in the coordination of many different processes.

It’s also been claimed from neuroimaging investigations that brain training can produce changes in the “hardwiring” of the brain. But whether these changes endure and what they truly signify remains open to question.

You could spend your time and money on learning an instrument instead.Marco Tedaldi

The jury is still out on brain training for otherwise healthy individuals. But if you’re considering taking it up, it’s important to consider that some of the principal proponents of brain training methods have a financial or other commercial stake in the packages they’re endorsing.

The key question you should ask yourself is the opportunity cost associated with brain training – what is it you are not doing in order to spend time “training your brain”?

In addition to financial expense, many brain-training packages involve considerable investment of your time over an extended period.

You might spend your time and money more effectively doing other things to improve your abilities, such as exercising, improving your diet, learning to play an instrument, or acquiring a new language.

These alternative pursuits confer the additional benefit of social interaction, which has clearly been demonstrated to benefit our brain health.

The Conversation

Jonathan Foster receives funding from the National Health and Medical Research Council and the Australian Research Council..

Other news

Huntington‘s disease: how brain training games could help

Huntington‘s disease: how brain training games could helpLia Koltyrina/ShutterstockIn the search for new treatments, science often focuses on medication first. But drugs aren’t the only way to fight illness, particularly when looking at brain diseases. My research looks into how playing specially designed computer games might help people who are living with Huntington’s disease. Huntington’s is a b...

The science, drugs and tech pushing our brains to new limits

The science, drugs and tech pushing our brains to new limitsJonathan Cohen/Flickr, CC BY-NCA recent explosion of neuroscience techniques is driving substantial advances in our understanding of the brain. Combined with developments in engineering, machine learning and computing this flowering has helped us enhance our cognitive abilities and potential. In fact, new research into the extraordinary machine in ...

Preview: ABC‘s Redesign my Brain with Todd Sampson

Preview: ABC‘s Redesign my Brain with Todd SampsonOver the show‘s three episodes, Todd Sampson tests whether it‘s possible to enhance his mind, using exercises designed by scientists. ABCWe live in an age of great public fascination with minds and brains; books about brain plasticity, for instance, regularly make the bestseller lists. This fascination is not merely the product of our thirst for kn...

How a simple brain training program could help you stay away from alcohol

How a simple brain training program could help you stay away from alcoholShutterstockAround one in five Australians will develop an alcohol use disorder, such as dependence, during their lifetime. Reports suggest some people have been drinking more during the COVID pandemic, potentially putting themselves at greater risk of becoming dependent. While some people will seek treatment for problem drinking, more than half of...

Is it possible to boost your intelligence by training? We reviewed three decades of research

Is it possible to boost your intelligence by training? We reviewed three decades of researchIt will certainly make you better at doing sudoku. Nicola Keegan/ShutterstockScientists achieved astonishing results when training a student with a memory training programme in a landmark experiment in 1982. After 44 weeks of practice, the student, dubbed SF, expanded his ability to remember digits from seven numbers to 82. However, this remarkable...
Contact: [email protected]